Chapter 50

Her mornings on Asphodel had become routine, if not rote.

(What is on the seventh page of the leftmost book? Maryam asked. Angharad rose to her feet, walked the hall two doors down and entered the bedroom. There were four books on the bed. She flipped open the leftmost to the requested page. It was a small journal, and that page held nothing but a sequence of inked numbers: seven, nineteen, three hundred and two, one.)

Letting out a long breath, Angharad opened her eyes and found an expectant Maryam looking at her from across the table, steel tip pen at the ready.

“Leftmost book, seventh page,” she said. “Seven, nineteen, three hundred and two, one.”

It had been one of the more interesting discoveries that everything she saw in a vision was temporarily fixed in her mind, near impossible to forget for at least a day afterwards. Maryam hummed, jotting down what had been said, then went down the hallway to check. She came back smiling.

“It is correct,” the pale-skinned woman happily announced. “And it was not knowledge I personally possessed, as Song was the one to write these down.”

Angharad slowly nodded.

“So the knowledge within my vision is not dependent on that of the people in my presence,” she said.

Which was for the best. Mind-reading was not forbidden under the Iscariot Accords, but it was mandatory to report and register. Maryam snorted.

“That is one test pointing in that direction,” she said. “I’m not willing to confidently repeat what you just said until at least another seven point the same way.”

While Angharad appreciated the thoroughness and would hardly oppose it when it was being put to work in her service, she was not trying to establish the limits of her contract up to some obscure Akelarre standard. As far as she was concerned, a truth had been learned. Another touch of color on the painting taking shape, establishing that her contract lent her true foresight and did not simply borrow from the minds around it to guess.

Angharad had believed this already proven, but Maryam insisted that the visions could not be treated as simply larger glimpses. It had almost irked her, a first, but now she was coming around to the notion. There was something… different about the visions. The glimpses felt like exactly that, a quick look at what lay ahead. Angharad remained apart from them. The visions, however, felt raw in a way that blurred the boundary between dream and material.

 Almost as if she lived them, though admittedly not as deeply as she had that first time on the Dominion.

The Izvorica finished jotting down her notes, then carefully blew at the ink ‘til it dried before closing the journal. Angharad waited patiently until she was done, then silently inquired as to whether they were done.

“I would not mind practicing your tell,” Maryam said, “but I believe we might run late if we do.”

“My affairs are already packed and aboard the coach,” Angharad told her, “but it might be for the best to end this now anyhow.”

The Black House coachman would be taking her to the northwestern ward – not on an official Watch coach, mind you, a rented one – and there the carriage that Lord Cleon had recommended her would be waiting for the longer trip out to the country. It would be two days of traveling by road to the Eirenos estate, and she was meant to stay at least two nights there before returning. Lord Cleon was to receive guests for a small soiree, but she would be arriving the day before that so he might show her the estate and they could go on a hunt together.

Given that the moment they left Tratheke the beautiful First Empire roads of the capital would be a thing of the past, to leave a little early could not hurt. The roads in Tratheke Valley were said to be bad enough that carriages habitually carried spare wheels and axles. Would that Angharad could ride a horse instead. She would tire after an hour or two, she expected, but she was barred from this regardless as her slow but steady recovery had to be hidden from the society she was joining.

It was her troubles that made her fine bait for the cult of the Golden Ram, though the more the Thirteenth discovered the more it seemed like that name might have become a façade for something darker.

“I need to prepare my own affairs for the trip back to the Rows anyhow,” Maryam said.

“Bringing flowers to the brackstone wall, I hear,” Angharad said.

And not entirely succeeding at hiding her skepticism, by the amused look on the other woman’s face.

“Not just any flowers, Asphodel crowns,” she replied. “They’ve a large place in the tale of the god Oduromai and echo strangely in the aether. If I can match that echo to whatever lies behind the shrine…”

“Then you could put a name to the imprisoned spirit,” Angharad finished, inclining her head in acknowledgement. “Even failing to match would be information, in a way.”

“Assuming I can feel anything through the brackstone,” Maryam said. “It is not a given.”

At least she would be safe even if her Signs turned on her again, Angharad thought. Captain Wen was heading out with her, as he had with the archives. She was beginning to wonder if the large Tianxi might not have decided on a favorite after all. They parted ways cordially, the noblewoman combing through her room one last time to ensure she had not forgotten anything.

She was about ready to believe so when there was a small knock against the doorway. She turned half-expecting Song to be there, but it was her uncle. Osian Tredegar came dressed in his fine blacks, smiling, and after she silently invited him in he closed the door. Not a simple goodbye, then.

“Word has come from the palace that our delegation will be taken to the shipyard tomorrow,” he plainly said. “Myself and three others, all covenanters.”

She slowly nodded.

“Is a tinker from the Deuteronomicon to accompany you?” Angharad asked.

Among the Umuthi Society, those were the men and women who studied aetheric machinery – and thus were most likely to recognize an infernal forge should they encounter one down there. Half-grimacing, Osian nodded.

“A Savant and a Laurel as well,” he said.

She raised an eyebrow at the last, until her uncle explained the woman in question was a cryptoglyph scholar. An Antediluvian shipyard was likely to be full of inscriptions in the First Empire’s scientific language, some of which might shed light on its original purpose.

“I wish you luck,” Angharad said, lowering her head.

She was not sure whether she ought to rejoice of or dread his visit to the shipyard and the news he would bring on his return.

“They can only keep us drugged for so long,” Uncle Osian quietly said. “It will give us a better idea of how close the entrance to the shipyard is to the capital.”

And the shipyard was to be where the infernal engine lay. Perhaps. It was not known for certain there was an infernal engine on Asphodel in the first place. Yet recent news had improved the odds in Angharad’s eyes. Twice now members of the Thirteenth had run into Lord Locke and Lady Keys in places they should not be, while Hage – a devil of some age – had passed down a stern warning to avoid angering them.

If the pair were ancient devils themselves, or at least Lady Keys as the one Tristan reported to be of unusual strength, then there must be a reason for their presence on Asphodel. She could think of few greater prizes for an annealed devil than an infernal forge, for their like endless font of lives but a helping pair of hands away. More worryingly, it might mean competing with an ancient devil for that prize.

Not a prospect Angharad was likely to survive at the moment.

“It will be all right, Angie,” her uncle said, squeezing her shoulder. “We approach answers with every step.”

The kindness in his eyes burned. She had kept the Thirteenth away from the machinations of the Lefthand House, for now, but she had already dragged Osian Tredegar deep into their net. Oh, he had involved himself of his own will but deep down Angharad knew she had wielded her own life like a knife to force him. The same reason he was helping her was why he deserved better.

Part of her resented that something was holding her back from taking the risks she needed to see her father out of Tintavel, but that anger smacked of shame. Her uncle had spent decades rising up the ranks of the Watch then put the work of a lifetime on the line for her. To help her save a man he did not even like. Angharad was not blind, the two were never close.

Uncle Osian did it all for love of her. How could there be honor in this, in making a good man ruin his life? There wasn’t. That was the hard truth of it, she admitted to herself. There was not a speck of honor in any of it, no matter how much she pulled and twisted the facts to try and make it otherwise.

“Imani Langa,” she blurted out.

Osian Tredegar blinked.

“She is the ufudu,” Angharad admitted.

“The captain of the Eleventh Brigade?” her uncle frowned.

She nodded.

“I do not think my visit to the country will see me in danger,” she said, “but the Sleeping God alone knows. Should I pass…”

“I will ensure she does not outlive you long,” Osian Tredegar calmly said.

There was not a hint of doubt in his eyes as he spoke the words. She believed him. Angharad passed a hand through her hair, biting her lip. That was not what she had meant.

“See to yourself first,” Angharad quietly replied. “Please. Use it however you can to remove yourself from this pit I dragged you into.”

“You did no such thing,” Osian denied.

Her lips thinned.

“In my heart, I am still the lady of Llanw Hall,” Angharad admitted. “I played at it with all the other nobleborn islanders, the lot of us crowding room and table pretending as if it were a salon and we were all rulers in the making. It felt…”

She grimaced.

“It felt like my right, to make the decisions I have,” she said. “Whatever I must to free my father. I thought I was being a lady, making the hard calls Mother so often spoke of. The costs to everyone around me were regrettable, but not regretted.”

Her uncle listened in silence, face inscrutable. She rubbed her forehead.

“But I am not lady of Llanw Hall,” Angharad said, though the words felt like molten iron. “And what I thought a lady’s refrain now sounds like the wailing of a child.”

An honorable woman would not have let it all turn out like this. Like some… endless twisting knot, a rope dragging ever more people into the pit. She had made bargains, cut corners, all because it felt hopeless to struggle otherwise. And for what? A liar’s promises. Bait she swallowed down to the last drop no matter how bitter the taste grew.

“It has not been a year since you watched it all burn, Angharad,” her uncle gently said. “You are… I do not expect you to embrace it so quickly, the black. It was not a life you sought. I did, as a young man, and still it took me time.”

She closed her eyes. He did not understand, not really. Could not. Osian Tredegar saw in her his sister’s ghost and loved the shade too much to glimpse through it at what his niece had become. The Fisher had chided Angharad, once, for clinging to the victories of a child while fighting a woman’s battles. And while the spirit was ancient and cruel, a tyrant of the Old Night, in its own mad way it saw things clearly.

It was time to grow up. Her debts were no one else’s to settle.

She kissed her uncle on the cheek, bade him goodbye and left him stand there troubled. Another regret, but the only words she had to soothe him were lies. The Thirteenth were waiting for her in the courtyard, chatting by the coach. Maryam and Tristan trading barbs, Song eyeing them amusedly. They were… They stood in the light of the Tratheke morning like a lit hearth, and Angharad a stranger. One of her own making.

“Tredegar, are you taking up lurking? Don’t put me out of a job, I need the salary.”

She answered Tristan’s teasing by approaching, the thief studying her face seriously as she did. Debts to settle, Angharad reminded herself. How stiff was her pride, that she must chew on it for months before she could swallow? Stiff enough she nodded at Tristan and shook a surprised Maryam’s hand before finally turning to Song. She breathed in.

“When I asked you about the death of Isabel Ruesta,” Angharad said, “I walked into that room having decided on the answer. For that, I apologize.”

Silver eyes met her own.

“Apology accepted,” Song Ren finally said.

The noblewoman stiffly inclined her head.

“When I return from the country,” Angharad continued, “I would ask you again.”

Her captain gave a slow, measured nod back.

“I await that conversation, then,” she simply said.

They left it at that. Debts to settle, Angharad thought again as she climbed onto the coach and the door was closed behind her. It had not felt good, swallowing her pride. She wished it had, that virtue would be sweet on the tongue, but it hadn’t.

But neither had treason, and she would sleep better after this.

Song had come to the rector’s palace to personally report matters best not put to paper, expecting the trip there and back to take up most of the time involved, but that had been foolish optimism on her part.

Lord Rector Evander, upon being informed that Song was to run down a lead concerning a potential second brackstone shrine, had made a snap decision. That was why, an hour and change after entering the palace, Song Ren was being glared at by Prefect Nestor – commander of the palace lictors, the Lord Rector’s personal guards among them. It was unfair of the man to be turning that ire her way when Song had spent the better part of half an hour trying to deny his king.

It was, unfortunately, difficult enough to refuse the Lord Rector anything even when he did not have something passingly resembling a valid point.

“Nestor, make your peace with it,” Evander Palliades advised. “My mind is made up.”

The commander of the lictors grit his teeth.

“At least let me send a whole squad with you,” he said.

Lord Rector Evander, dark eyes glittering with amusement, turned to Song with a cocked eyebrow. Would that she could strangle him. He knew exactly what she was doing, foisting off the answer on her.

“This is meant to be a discreet investigation, prefect,” she said. “Twenty heavily armed lictors surrounding us at all times would be too conspicuous.”

The glare deepened, still turned on her. He could not afford to be angry at his master so Song was paying the price on their behalf.

“Two guards are too few,” Prefect Nestor said. “Since your brigade has failed to find the assassin, Captain Ren, it -”

Enough.

“My brigade is not contracted to find your assassin,” Song icily replied. “If the lictors are incapable of doing so, hire a Watch team to make up for your incompetence – another team, as mine is already on contract.”

“Watch your tone, girl,” the prefect warned.

“Watch your words, prefect,” she flatly retorted. “I have tolerated, in the spirit of cooperation between Asphodel and the Conclave, the throne’s constant impositions on my brigade’s contracted duties. Yet there are limits.”

She smiled blandly.

“Further interference will force me to consider the throne of Asphodel in breach of contract, and thus any obligations on the Thirteenth Brigade’s part voided. We can withdraw to the Lordsport by day’s end, if you would like.”

The older man gritted his teeth, looking like he wanted nothing more than to start snarling, but he had to know that he had no real grounds to complain on – he had been out of line. Instead he looked askance to the Lord Rector, whose eyebrow remained cocked.

“I spoke in haste,” Prefect Nestor reluctantly said. “Yet it remains that His Excellency descending into an unsavory part of the city with only yourself and two guards as escort is an entirely unnecessary risk.”

“I agree,” Song said, to his surprise. “While I concede that the throne has a vested interest in what is being investigated, I would prefer an observer to accompany me instead. As I have repeatedly stated.”

She turned a cold gaze on Lord Rector Evander, who idly waved her irritation away.

“The matter in question is of importance to House Palliades and must remain secret,” the bespectacled young man said. “I will not bring in another soul when all that is required of me is to walk down a street and listen while Captain Song asks a few questions. It would beirresponsible of me.”

Prefect Nestor looked like he shared Song’s opinion, which was that the irresponsibility in play was Evander Palliades putting himself in a situation where the bullet put in his skull would become the opening shot of a civil war over his succession, but he could no more argue than her. He was a retainer, not someone who could question his master over the affairs of his own house.

And House Palliades had a right to keep the matter of the brackstone shrines and aether seal secret, Watch bylaws guaranteed it. Song had checked. Thrice, in different languages, to see if there might be any wiggle room using a different translation. Unfortunately, the Laurels were very thorough in their work.

“Most of the traveling will be done by coach,” Song offered. “And there is no reason that a larger force could not be waiting inside the ward to escort him back in greater numbers, so long as it remains covert.”

Much of the heat gone out of his eyes, though not all, Prefect Nestor curtly nodded.

“I will arrange that immediately,” he said. “Your Excellency, Captain Ren, please excuse me.”

She simply nodded, while Lord Rector Evander smiled and leaned over to share a few quiet words before letting the old prefect leave. The look he turned on her afterwards almost seemed approving, the warmth in those dark eyes making her a little uncomfortable.

“You handled yourself well,” Evander Palliades said. “Captain Duan would be pleased, I’m sure. Nestor’s a tough old hound, half the reason I picked him as prefect is that he is too stubborn to be bent.”

“He is also correct regarding this entire affair,” Song flatly replied. “It is an unnecessary risk, and while I acknowledge that you have a right to attend I do not believe the reasons you gave for it are your true ones.”

He leaned back into his seat, lips twitching for some strange reason. Had he somehow failed to grasp that she was implying him to be a selfish prick complicating her life for the sake of his petty whims? He had demonstrated not to be a dimwit in other regards, which made his reaction all the more baffling.

“The last few days have been smothering,” he acknowledged. “I cannot so much as walk down a hall without a full squad of lictors behind and ahead of me.”

“My sympathies,” Song blandly said. “Unfortunately, your inclination to use my brigade a means to escape your situation puts us in the position of being responsible for your life even as you carelessly risk it.”

“It is our lictor escorts that would be responsible,” he denied.

Song flatly stared him down until he coughed and looked away. If Evander Palliades was killed while tagging along on a Watch investigation, it would be puerile to pretend that the blackcloaks would not get the lion’s share of the blame whether lictors were present or not. It was not at all unlikely that the Watch would end up blamed for the ensuing civil war as well.

While strictly speaking getting the Lord Rector killed on her watch would not end their contract with the throne Asphodel, thus failing the yearly test, Song suspected such a thing might… detrimentally affect the Thirteenth’s performance assessment.

“I’m not unaware that you would be made liable for my decision, should some catastrophe strike,” the Lord Rector admitted, and straightened in his seat. “I will obey your orders in the field, Captain Song, and find a way to make it up to you.”

The informally spoken, almost teasing last part had her flushing in irritation.

“You will dress as a merchant,” she ordered. “You will not speak unless I allow it, and your escorts will obey my orders until your life is demonstrably in danger.”

He nodded, smiling, and the warm satisfaction it brought was purely that of a daughter of Tianxia subjecting a despot to the rightful yoke of law.

“Then, while I continue to protest, I reluctantly agree to your accompanying me to the site in question,” Song said.

“Capital,” Evander amiably replied. “Where is this site, anyhow? You did not clarify beyond the northeastern ward.”

He paused, coughing into his fist.

“Will we be passing through the ‘Reeking Rows’?”

He said those words, she observed with some amusement, much in the same tone her sisters used to talk about that shrine to the White-Tailed Consort in the woods a few hours away from their home. Scandalized fascination. She cleared her throat.

“We will not,” she said.

She would not have thought his face one suited to pouting, between the stubble and the angular features, but some might have called the expression on his face endearing.

“Though we will come close,” she added, and he lit up. “I take it you have not visited that part of the city often?”

“Try never,” he replied. “It was the first Palliades rector who ordered that district’s consolidation, so it has long been a source of curiosity to me. I’ve not had opportunity to visit the ward before.”

“You’ve never set foot there?” she asked, honestly surprised.

Disreputable or not, it contained almost a quarter of his capital.

“First I was too young, then under regency,” he said. “And after I took the crown, the first few years were… difficult. Lady Floros prepared me to reign, but Palliades or not I did not command the respect she does. It was as if the machinery of state had rusted overnight, and every failure had my name written on it.”

“You seem to have grown beyond those beginnings,” Song honestly said.

While his rule was weak, it was not through any particular failing of his own and he was taking steps to remedy this – indeed, his success seemed to be why his enemies were growing bolder. Song felt a twinge of guilt at keeping from Evander that his suspicions were correct, that there was a coup brewing under his feet and the Council of Ministers was up to its neck in it, but she ruthlessly rubbed it out.

There could be no good kings and the Watch did not take sides.

“That is what I owe my name and my people,” he said, smiling wanly. “It does not leave room for much else, but my father liked to say that duty is not a verse but refrain – it will return so long as we keep singing, and what else is there but to sing?”

It was easier when you thought of kings as distant figures on towering thrones, Song thought. Before you saw what lay under the crown and the dragon robe, the flesh and bones. The kings of the Feichu Tian did not get tired or wistful, did not sound determined to filially live up to their legacy. They did not sound like they were drowning in their own reign.

It changed nothing, she reminded herself.

And yet half a smile fought its way through Song’s better judgment, as she cleared her throat and drew him out of the soft melancholy he’d fallen into.

“To answer your earlier question in full,” she said, “we are to visit a paying establishment.”

“A tavern?” he asked, cocking his head to the side.

“They do serve wine, I hear,” she noted, “but I expect that is not the main draw.”

“An eatery?”

Her smile widened.

“Have you ever been in a brothel before, Your Excellency?”

By the way he choked, she would hazard he had not.

It was the first day of the investigation, so Tristan took the time to case the place. To ask around, spend a few coppers and get a feel for it.

The Kassa family’s workshop on Chancery Lane was not a single edifice but three of them, tightly clustered together and effectively occupying an overlarge city block. Two of those buildings, large one-story squares with a tall ceiling and a flat roofs covered with gas lamps, where their weavers turned the wool imported from the mountains into the cloth shipped out to the Lordsport. From there it was headed mostly towards southern Izcalli, Tristan learned.

Asphodel wool was considered of lesser quality and was thus sold at more affordable prices, often undyed. Cheap clothing was attractive to the Izcalli lords bordering Tianxia and the Someshwar, who always had fresh serfs to clothe and no great desire to dress them expensively. It was a common enough sort of trade for small Trebian islands, though often Tianxi and Someshwari traders stepped in as middlemen to fill their pockets.

Profits cared little for irony.

The two squares had been turned into one large building, the space between them walled in with cheaper stone than the Antediluvian sort while the separating walls were knocked down to make of them a single large floor. Not so with the third edifice, a three-story building pressed against the side of the others that had been turned into dormitories for the workers – with the nice, windowed upper floor reserved for foremen and overseers.

The alley door that the Brazen Chariot had mentioned was a narrow slice of street between the Kassa workshop and rented warehouses, a back entrance that should lead directly to the workshop floor. Had the assassin been unable to secure a bed in the dormitories, or perhaps been afraid that in a crowd someone was bound to talk? That might be it, if Song was correct and that illusory contract had to be consciously used – those tattoos were distinctive, and sleep would have revealed her true face for anyone caring to look.

Satisfied he had the layout of the place comfortably settled in his mind’s eye, Tristan began making more pointed inquiries. Was the Kassa workshop hiring? What kind of workers, what were the wages, who should be sought to get a foot in? There were taverns close, cheap enough they were meant to cater to the workers and not the whipmen, and there he found fertile grounds for answers so long as he spent some coin on drink or food.

“The Kassa are always hiring,” a wan-faced barmaid told him. “But not for the good wages you’re looking for, boy. Those weavers are locked up in contracts so tight not even Old Dragfoot could hammer them open, the Kassa keep that in-house. They only take fullers and traveling men.”

Tristan swallowed a mouthful of watery stew, forcing himself not to grimace. Watch meals had spoiled him.

“Do they full with bats or feet?” he asked.

“They’re traditional, so it’s feet in the piss for you,” she chuckled.

Not ideal. He wasn’t too proud to spend hours stepping on woolen cloth in a tub full of human piss, but the stink would be hard to wash off. Not ideal to sneak around after.

“And the traveling men?”

“They’ll work you to the bone,” the waitress warned. “Not just warehouse work, but riding the coaches and filling in everything that needs to be filled. You might just end up stepping in the piss anyway, for lesser pay.”

Ah, Tristan thought, but it also sounds like work that’ll get me in everywhere. He pretended to heed her advice, made sure to tip her as well as the fresh migrant he was pretending to be could, then moved on to another haunt. He slipped in with a wave of hammer-men from a larger workshop down the road, waiting until they’d had a few beers with their meal to ingratiate himself with further drinks and ask his questions.

“Don’t know who told you Kassa would take you, but they were full of shit,” a big man called Pantelis laughed. “They only hire by recommendation, even their traveling men – had trouble a few years back with a fire they blamed the Anastos for, now they’re careful as cats.”

“Try the Euripis warehouses, down on Charon Street,” his wife advised. “They take in Sacromontans, and the pay’s shit but it comes with a bed and one meal a day.”

The next crowd told him much the same, though they warned one of the Euripis foremen liked pretty boys and did not like it when they refused. When he asked about how one might get recommended to the Kassa, the answers were not promising.

“Work a year or two for them at their northwest warehouses,” he was told. “Or have a cousin inside.”

He picked a particularly drunk woman to ask about bribes, counting on her not remembering his face in a few hours, and was told it wouldn’t work.

“If you’re caught taking coin they slice you,” she said. “No one’ll risk it for some nobody like you, kid.”

She was likely right, unless he offered a suspiciously large bribe that might just get him outed anyway.

Fortunately, through the mass of largely useless dross he’d gathered through hours of this he found one useful detail: the Kassa warehouses in the northwest were in bed with the local basileia. And, more importantly for him, that relationship was close enough that recommendations handed out by said basileia – no one could tell him the name – were enough to get you in.

That, Tristan decided, sounded like an angle he could work.

Irritating as it was to have the Lord Rector foisted onto her for the trip, at least Evander did not waste time getting ready.

By the turn of the hour they’d left the palace, smuggled out with their two lictor minders on the supply lift, and boarded a coach. Forty lictors would be following in a fleet of coaches after a delay, but Song intended to be done with the investigation long before they could ruin her efforts blundering about.

The two hard-faced men accompanying them screamed ‘soldier’ even out of lictor’s uniform between the blades, the scars and the ramrod straight posture, but Song was hoping they would be taken as hired guards for a wealthy young man trying out the seedier side of Tratheke. Lord Rector Evander, despite wearing clothes in muted colors and no jewelry – even his spectacles had been changed for a set with smaller lenses and a cheaper iron mount – could not pass as anything but ‘well bred’.

It was nothing he could help: soft hands, well-kept hair and the easy confidence of man who’d never had to lower his eyes in his life were not something that could be hidden by a change of clothes. His barely hidden enthusiasm and curiosity were, but Song saw no point in asking. On the contrary, better he marked as a young master out on an adventure than anything needing deeper thought.

If atrocious price gouging on the wine and room were the worst they had to suffer today, she would count herself lucky.

In a drab brown doublet and workman’s trousers, his hair kept under a cap, Evander Palliades looked at the run-down streets of the Reeking Rows’ approach as if they were the most interesting thing he’d ever seen. Song kept close, hand near her blade, and watched him as he eyed streaks of filth on alley walls not with disgust but curiosity. She shot him a dubious look.

“I had read myrmekes ate such things,” the Lord Rector said. “I wonder if it is the Rows that drove off local lares.”

Song hummed.

“I have not seen stray dogs or rats here,” she acknowledged. “But that is not so rare in the poorer districts of any city.”

Anything went into the cookpot, when you grew hungry enough.

“Tratheke has little vermin compared to the other cities of Asphodel,” Evander told her. “Most of the city is stone or brass, it repels many insects.”

And with them the creatures that fed on them, presumably. Song had not fallen behind on her Teratology readings so knew every animal to be part of an intricate cycle – a part of that cycle could not be yanked out without consequences rippling out.

“I expect the smell around here would drive off men as well, if they could leave,” Song mused.

He glanced at her through his spectacles.

“You disapprove of the arrangement?”

She frowned.

“You do not?”

“It was done for sensible reasons, which have not changed,” the Lord Rector informed her.

“It sensibly ruined a quarter of your capital, or near enough,” Song replied.

“Those trades have to go somewhere,” Evander said. “It cannot be either of the southern wards, and what use is there in moving them northwest instead? There is no machine there to blow the air upwards.”

“The air only became poisonous because of the concentration of trades,” she said. “If you dispersed them across the city-”

“Then I have districts up in arms about their homes suddenly smelling like tanneries and slaughterhouses,” he said. “The dye workshops used to be in the southwestern ward, Song, and there were riots during summer when it went too long without raining. The fumes from the heat were deadly to children.”

“And your solution to this is making a district where the desperate are forced to work knowing their lungs rot for it?” she replied, unimpressed. “The entire ward might well be uninhabitable if not for the Antediluvian wind machine.”

Whatever those great rotating blades were truly for, in practice they blew the reek upwards.

“The edge of the district connects to two major avenues and the broadest canal in Tratheke,” Evander said. “The trades are clustered there because the ward is far from where the goods are headed and those are the easiest paths to remedy this.”

“An argument that matters much to the magnates owning those slaughterhouses,” she said, “but I expect rather less to those dying in them. The latter are your subjects as well, Lord Rector.”

“And what is your solution, then?” he replied in irritation.

“Spread out the trades within the whole northeastern district,” she said. “Keep only the worst near the machine. Air in the Rows will thin out and the ward becomes inhabitable again, which will draw people back into the empty districts.”

“That would mean reclaiming the ward,” he said. “Which means patrols and clearing out the lemures, thus expanding the lictors. Which is expensive. Then for there to be a wide movement of populace I would need to either offer a bounty to families moving here, expensive, or force them to move – tyrannical and still expensive. It means refurbishing the streets, the lamps, the lesser canals. It means bringing magistrates to settle disputes and collect royal rents.”

He scoffed.

“What you suggest is the founding of a colony town within Tratheke,” Evander said.

Song nodded, for that was entirely true. She only knew so much of the unique structures of this ruin-city, but the bare numbers of it she had considered before speaking.

“An endeavor that would take years, significant coin and much effort,” she agreed. “It would also ease the crowding of the southern wards, bring in revenue through taxes and royal rents as well as drain the recruitment pool of your basileias.”

She paused.

“But, most important of all,” Song pointedly said, “you would cease to tacitly endorse the poisoning of your own subjects less than an hour’s walk away from your own palace.”

His eyes narrowed.

“Even if I could spare the coin for that – which, between bringing the lictors up to strength and restoring a First Empire shipyard, I assure you I do not – it would not matter,” he said. “Such a great investment would not be solely mine to decide, it must be approved by the Council of Ministers.”

Song frowned. That, admittedly, she had not considered.

“And they would not allow you to spend that much improving Tratheke when the current state of affairs suits them better,” she said.

“They would see it as gilding the Palliades reputation with the people and strengthening my grip on the city, neither of which they will let me spend a copper on if they could prevent it,” he flatly said. “There are checks on my power. Lawful and not, for if you imagine for a moment the Trade Assembly would not pour a fortune into that district colony to steal it out from under me you are being most naïve.”

If they can better serve the people than the throne, they would be right to, Song thought. A king’s power first sought to preserve itself, then doled out kindness like crumbs. Only authority issued by citizens and answerable to them could truly be relied on to observe their dignity.

“The power of thrones is always contested,” Song simply said.

He looked at her through those brass spectacles, dark eyes flat.

“Your republics war on each other constantly through mercenaries, squabbling over farmland and profits,” Evander Palliades said. “The children of your bureaucrats are nearly guaranteed to win such offices, your elections are awash with gold and blood, even your famous Luminary lottery is rigged so that the three most powerful republics always win.”

His brow rose.

“It seems to me that a republic is not a remedy so much as a different set of troubles.”

“Tianxia is no less troubled by evils than any other land,” Song acknowledged, to his visible surprise.

“But?”

“But when our rulers fail to end these evils, they are removed and replaced by those who will,” Song said. “Without needing to wait out a lifetime or wage a civil war. We are a method, not a result.”

“Results are what matters to a nation,” the Lord Rector dismissed. “The rest is wind.”

Song looked around her, at the dying district.

“As you say, Your Excellency,” she replied.

His face tightened. Her words put silence between them all the way to the edifice with the yellow crescent hung outside. It was not wise to anger the ruler of the land one must fulfill a contract in, but Song did not regret her words. Truth was truth, and if the man insisted on debating her she would not lie to assuage his feelings. Besides, if he was miffed enough by her words perhaps he would find another sniffer to accompany him on his outings.

It would be better for them both if he did.

The brothel was exactly as she had been told, the sign with a yellow crescent its only advertisement. It was three stories tall and rather broad, from the outside looking more like a Port Allazei hostel than a den of debauchery – though it was still in the stone, green glass and brass typical of Tratheke. There was no one at the door and the windows were all shuttered tight, but there were lights inside.

“On me,” Song told the Lord Rector and his escorts. “Follow and do not speak.”

She waited for nods from all three before entering. The entrance hall was dimly lit with bad oil lamps – not Glare oil, by the glow – and it smelled strongly of incense. Not the good kind, and Song had prayed at enough street shrines to know what cheap incense smelled like. A man with a club and a dead eye waited there, but he let them pass without a word. It was not a madam who welcomed them at the desk but a procurer, a small man with dark hair and blue eyes dressed more like a shopkeeper than a flesh peddler.

He smiled easily and shallowly, eyes always moving between them.

“Welcome, welcome,” he said. “The Amber Crescent is always pleased to receive guests.”

It took effort for her not to inform him that crescent’s shade of yellow had not been anywhere near amber. His eyes lingered on the two lictors behind them.

“Especially those with coin.”

The procurer licked his lips.

“What pleasure can I provide you?” he asked, gaze darting between her and the Lord Rector. “Most of my girls are free, though should you be interested in boys instead…”

Song took out a small pouch of silver and placed it on the desk. The upside of the Lord Rector having come along was that she could bill the payment to the throne instead of paying out from brigade funds.

“We require not your girls but your discretion,” she said.

Eyes flicked between her and Evander again. He tested the weight of the pouch, looking pleased.

“Of course,” he smiled. “A room, and never a word will pass these lips.”

“Prepare it,” Song ordered. “And while we wait, I was told you have a selection of wines?”

“My cellar is yours, my lady,” the procurer hastily said. “I can have brought up-”

“We have very particular tastes,” Song blandly said. “We will choose ourselves.”

Another piece of silver was put on the desk.

“Unless you object?”

The small man picked it up, adding it to the earlier pouch. He’d unstrung that so discreetly she never noticed.

“I would not dare,” the procurer smiled. “Verico will show you the way to the cellar. I will personally see to your room, my lady.”

“Do,” Song thinly smiled back.

Verico was the name of the one-eyed guard, who kept silent as he led them past a few closed doors to a set of narrow stairs leading down into the basement. The door at the bottom was not locked. Song glanced at the Lord Rector meaningfully and he gestured for the lictors to stay out, remaining on the main floor with Verico – who handed them a stinking, smoky lamp before closing the door behind them.

The basement was a disheveled pile of barrels and bottles, not all of which were on racks. Many were simply on the floor, there for anyone to trip over, and some of the bottles in straw-stuffed crates were empty. Song’s fingers clenched at the sight but she kept herself in check. She was not going to organize a brothel basement for that seedy man upstairs, even if someone ought to.

“I don’t recognize any of those bottles,” Evander Palliades said, sounding amused. “And some are larger than I thought wine bottles even came in.”

“We are not here for the wine,” Song murmured back.

Lamp in hand she pushed through the mess to find what they truly had come from. The back wall, while obstructed with barrels and a collapsed shelf, turned out to be exactly what the Brazen Chariot thug had said: brackstone, entirely so. The Lord Rector, come to stand by her side, clicked his tongue.

“So your signifier was right,” he said. “There’s more than one shrine – and unless there’s some other aether prison out there, these are the anchors for it.”

Song slowly nodded.

“Not here,” she said. “Grab a bottle and we use the room for a span, then head back.”

He chose a bottle of bright red glass with a seal on it, snatching it out of the crate, and followed her up. The procurer ‘preparing’ the room for them turned out to be changing the sheets on a miserable straw mattress and topping up the oil lamps. Two clay cups were brought up as well, clean enough Song might be willing to drink something out of them.

The small man might have tried to eavesdrop on them, she figured, if not for the two lictors that went to stand by the door. They had naturally discouraging expressions.

Evander closed the door behind him, and while Song sat on the bed after inspecting it enough to be reasonably sure it did not bear lice he broke the seal on the bottle and took a sniff.

“Cherries?” he muttered.

He poured them both a cup, but she merely held hers after it was handed.

“You have never heard of these shrines, I take it,” she said. “Is there truly no record of their construction?”

“If there are, I do not know them,” Evander admitted as he turned as chair to face her. “My family has journals dating back to its ascension to the throne, but they do not mention anything like this. Mostly Lord Rector Charilaos was trying to figure out which noble bride he could pick without getting assassinated.”

He grimaced.

“No one expected House Lissenos to be so suddenly snuffed out,” he said. “Charilaos Palliades was a compromise candidate, not a lord anyone expected to ever come near the throne. Our ancestral lands are a goat farm, for Oduromai’s sake.”

“I thought your family were the closest relatives to House Lissenos,” Song said.

“That became true,” he said, “after they spent two decades and change purging the lesser branches of their house following a spectacularly botched coup by their closest kin. Before that Charilaos was, I think, fifty-fourth in the line of succession? The genealogy books of the time don’t even mention him by name, only our house at large.”

Evander snorted.

“I doubt the time he spent in the presence of the last Lissenos rector ever reached the sum of an hour. He was not someone House Lissenos would have shared ancient family secrets with.”

“So the knowledge might have been lost when they died out,” she said. “Did they not leave behind records of their own?”

“Everything we inherited is in the private archives,” Evander said.

“Implying there is more in someone else’s hands,” she noted.

“The interregnum between the end of Lissenos and the coronation of Charilaos Palliades left the palace in the hands of the steward of the time,” he said. “Lady Myrto Eirenos.”

Her brow rose, impressed at the breadth of his knowledge.

“I had no idea before I read the journals yesterday,” he drily told her. “Charilaos was convinced she robbed the palace of everything that wouldn’t be noticed missing and stewed for a decade that there was not much he could do about it.”

“Are the Eirenos not minor vassals to Tratheke?” she asked.

They did not sound like all that troublesome an opponent for the lords of all Asphodel, however precarious their throne.

“Back in those days they owned about a tenth of Tratheke Valley,” he said. “They had to sell most of their land when their mine on Arke ran dry and debts were called, keeping mostly the hunting lodges that are their sole current claim to relevance. Even maintaining those is stretching their means.”

That, Song thought, would have been very useful to know before Angharad left for the Eirenos manor. Was it too late to send a messenger after her? She had only been gone for hours, it might not be. Song would ask Wen what means they had at their disposal to contact her. It was frustrating that they could not rely too much on Black House for it, lest Angharad be outed as a watchwoman. As her silence lingered, Evander cleared his throat.

“You believe the cult of the Golden Ram to be related to this imprisoned god, then?” he asked.

“The last such cult existed during the Ataxia and was used a puppet by the god known as the Hated One,” she said. “My Navigator found evidence – circumstantial – that these brackstone shrines might have been built shortly after the end of Ataxia.”

She paused.

“Now the containment layer is found breached while the Golden Ram cult makes a sudden resurgence, deepening its ties with those nobles most likely to plunge Asphodel into civil war. It has a conspiracy’s shape.”

“Yet your report claims an aether lock is meant to starve gods to death,” he noted. “If the Hated One is the god that escaped, then it was inside for over a century: would it then truly settle for impersonating the god of a minor cult and feeding on dregs of worship? That seems unusually restrained of a starving beast.”

That was… a very good point, admittedly. One neither she nor Maryam had considered.

“We do not yet have the whole picture,” Song admitted. “Leads are still being pursued.”

And it was a relief that their growing theory, the resurgence of the Hated One and the ties to the Council of Ministers, was proving to have flaws. Song would admit as much to herself. For if that was the truth of this mystery, then it followed that the assassin was not in the employ of the cult – because if they were ready to pull the trigger on their coup and forcefully seize the capital, they already would have.

Which left the Yellow Earth as the likely culprit for the attempt, considering the assassin was Tianxi and had fled to a workshop believed to have ties to the local sect.

Fingering Tianxia for the crime, because it surely would be all Ten Republics that got the blame and not some radical Yellow Earth faction, would sink Ren name deeper into the mud back home. She would not put it beyond some Yellow Earth sects to vilify her to draw the ire away from their own comrades, a fresh heaping of curses tossed onto her family’s shrine.

Evander risked a sip of his chosen wine, grimaced at the taste then took a deeper one.

“Horrid,” he cheerfully said. “You should try it, Song. We ought to be in here at least half an hour before leaving, lest we stand out in the wrong way.”

Song snorted, trying a sip and finding no trace of the purported cherries – the wine tasted, if anything, like… plums? Overripe plums, maybe. Regardless, it was just as horrid as promised. She swallowed an almost teasing question about taking only half an hour. A thought best buried very, very deep.

The Lord Rector drained his cup in a few long sips before pouring himself a second, the most Song had ever seen him drink. He usually watered his wine. Setting aside his cap, the man brushed back his long hair and let out a sigh. Evander Palliades had almost insultingly pretty hair, for a man. It was quite eye-catching, especially when he tossed it about like some young lion.

“It is not a good time for old gods to return to haunt us,” Evander said. “The city is a powder keg and this has the look of lit match.”

“The god might still be largely imprisoned,” Song told him. “Squeezing out through the cracks could be the work of years yet.”

“Chaos does not need reasons, only an excuse,” he quoted, drinking again.

Quoting Soyarabai, but she would forgive it since it was from her only good work. She should have stuck to philosophy and admitted her unfitness for serious scholarly work.

“The Council of Ministers will try to knock me off the throne the moment they think they have a chance and the Trade Assembly might well attempt the same to keep them off it,” Evander ruefully said.

The Ministers are already brewing a coup, Song thought, wishing she could tell him. Whatever his flaws, he seemed a better man than those trying to replace him. He emptied his cup, then set it down.

“You weren’t wrong, about the Rows,” he suddenly said. “Maybe not right, either, but…”

He laughed mirthlessly.

“Tacitly endorsing the poisoning of my subjects less than an hour’s walk away from my own palace,” Evander murmured. “Now there is a turn of phrase. One that I will not be forgetting anytime soon.”

Song said nothing, only watching him.

“I’m so close I can feel it,” he told her, biting his lip in frustration. “I only need to last through a year, maybe two, and my position will strong enough to reach terms with them. To finally do something more than just… fight to stay seated where I am.”

Only it was not so simple, was it?

“That won’t be the end of it. You will fight them your whole life, Evander, or others like them,” Song honestly said. “All that will change is who has the most guns and gold on their side.”

He turned a bright gaze on her. The drink could not have touched him so quick, she knew, but she almost believed it anyway looking at that expression on his face.

“Twelve days you have been on this island, Song Ren, and I have gotten more truth out of you than I have from anyone else in the last twelve years,” Evander Palliades chuckled. “It is madness.”

Song’s jaw clenched.

“I have been too familiar,” she said. “I will-”

“No,” Evander said. “Not that. This.”

He leaned in, glasses askew, and Song froze. And was tempted to remain frozen, to let it happen. It was not her mistake, if he was the one kissing her. And she was… curious.

But she was also a Ren.

Song drew back, putting a hand on his shoulder to stop him. She shook her head. The Lord Rector immediately stopped, then turned red in mortification. He flinched away like he had been burned.

“Apologies, Captain Ren,” he croaked out. “I was, I thought-”

He coughed.

“The wine,” she evenly said.

“Yes, the wine,” he awkwardly said. “Please forget I ever…”

“It is forgotten,” Song lied.

Neither of them spoke another word for the next twenty minutes, or dared to look at each other.

With the day’s work done and some time to kill before the evening meal at Black House, Tristan decided to allow himself a small indulgence: namely, investigating how hard it would be to break into the Nineteenth Brigade’s secret safehouse.

He picked up his burglar’s kit and took a roundabout route back to the dead-end alley he’d watched them go into, first taking a look at the surroundings. Of the half dozen or so buildings around there only two currently seemed in use, one being the Nineteenth’s rental. The other was a suspiciously clean two-story house whose shutters and locks had recently been changed and were of visibly better quality than the rest of the house.

They were also the kind that didn’t let sound out, which reeked to Tristan of coterie torture chamber until he climbed up on a neighboring roof and got a sniff at the scent wafting off the house’s second story. Poppy, and not some extract for the pain – the kind you stuffed in pipes and smoked. This was someone’s private drug den, then, not an interrogation pit. Probably some magnate or magnate’s kid who didn’t want to be known as a poppy fiend and figured that renting a den in the worst part of the southwestern ward counted as discretion.

The rest of the dead end was, if not exactly in ruins, then close to it: the houses were full of holes, be it in the walls or roof, and there were no shutters in the windows. As seemed common practice in Tratheke they had been raided for stone, brass and tiles then left to take the wind. No beggars had made a home there, which told Tristan whoever owned these regularly had them cleared by either hired men or the lictors. There would have been takers otherwise, no matter the holes in the roof.

The alley was less than half an hour of walk away from some of the liveliest streets of one of the richest wards in the city, as fine begging grounds as one could ask for. It brought out a shallow sort of amusement, to see that even in Tratheke the rich were willing to pay to keep their property free of rats even when they had no use for it.

The drug den was not in use at the moment – unless the fiend was sleeping it off inside – so Tristan allowed himself to take his time studying the Nineteenth’s rental. Fortuna whined at being asked to keep guard at the corner and kept returning to his side, but he ignored her. Two shuttered windows facing the street, heavy planks with brass stripes keeping them in place. None of that Asphodelian green glass behind them, so raising the bars might well let him inside.

He refrained.

“Just go inside,” Fortuna whined. “Come on, I bet they left all sorts of stuff lying around.”

“Cressida was here,” he replied. “And if I were her, I’d snare the place to know if someone came in.”

“You think she put something on the windowsill?” the goddess asked, looking enthused at the thought.

He nodded and she brightened further. The Lady of Longs Odds loved complications, so long as they were inflicted upon anyone but her. Should it be otherwise they would, of course, be found out as fundamentally unfair and morally intolerable.

“And likely the door as well,” Tristan added.

“I’ll leave you to it, then,” she drawled, vanishing.

If he had asked her to look inside the house for him a minute ago she would have agreed immediately, but now it was all but certain should he request it Fortuna would pretend to be hard of hearing. The thief did not mind. Opportunities to ply his craft with such low stakes were passing rare, and he must keep his skills sharp. Growing to rely too much on the goddess’ eyes would leave him lost without her aid.

The lock on the front door was child’s play, a tumble lock he could have done one-eyed with a hand tied behind his back, but he refrained again. Instead he brought up his lantern, peering at the small gap between door and doorway. There was nothing so obvious as string, but he thought he might be seeing a thin filament that could be a blonde hair. Tristan hummed, stepping away.

There were no shutters on the second story, but there was a chimney coming out of the rooftop. He slipped into the pilfered house to the right of the Nineteenth’s rental, up the skeleton of stairs then through a hole in the roof to reach the spread of tiles there. Given how closely clustered the buildings were, it was barely a leap to cross over to the other roof. He silently tread over the angled tiles to the chimney, hiding from the street through the angle and putting his bag down.

Fortuna, predictably, took the first halfway decent excuse to abandon her post and join him on the roof. She sat on the other side of the jutting chimney, skirts spilling out on either side like a small red tide, and golden eyes eagerly peered downwards.

“You want to sneak in through there?” she asked.

“Maybe,” Tristan hedged, removing a small mirror from his bag.

His lantern was already shuttered down to the barest slice, so it was just a matter of carefully angling the light and mirror before he could have a look down the chimney. It’d been cleaned, he found, but not recently: little soot but much dust. More importantly, leaning back and sweeping with the reflected light he found there were no caltrops at the bottom and no iron grid preventing entry.

“Cressida, you amateur,” he crowed. “We always cover the chimney, you ought to know better.”

“While this is the most interesting you’ve been all day,” Fortuna said, peering down, “is there a point to anything you’re doing?”

He shrugged.

“Might be the Nineteenth left papers lying around. There could be information to pass to Song about their investigation.”

“She could just ask Captain Tozi,” Fortuna said. “They seem friendly. Are you sure this isn’t about showing Cressida you’re the better Mask?”

“That has nothing to do with it,” Tristan lied.

She squinted at him for a moment.

“I believe you,” she lied back.

And on that merry note, he packed the mirror away and instead took out the necessary supplies: gloves and rags. The rest of the bag would only be a hindrance, no need to bring it.

He did not jump in immediately, carefully testing the chimney walls instead. Without much soot the stone was not too slippery, though it’d still be no easy task to make his way down without breaking a leg falling. With gloves and boots he managed, scooting down slowly and carefully until he was close enough to the bottom to let himself drop. There were some loose stones about halfway up, whose location he committed to memory for the climb back up that lay in his future.

The hearth was spotlessly clean but his boots were not, so he stood on the edge of the hearthstone and wiped both the stone and his boots clean before putting away his dirtied gloves so he would leave no visible mark.

His first impression of the Nineteenth Brigade’s safehouse was that it was derelict.

Probably the single cheapest place they had been able to find in the southwestern ward, he figured. It was a single large room at the bottom, where he’d entered, and what little furniture there was all boasted missing legs or cut up surfaces. By the height of holes in the wall there’d once been cupboards hung on the side wall, perhaps a kitchen, but those were the only trace of it left. The only fresh addition here was a barrel of water, which the Nineteenth must have bought at the market.

Upstairs was, if anything, even more desolate. There were two rooms, one of which had effectively collapsed when part of the roof caved in – it could not be seen from the outside, though no doubt the elements would eventually finish digging their way in. He’d bet rain went right through already.

They’d put the chamber pot in there. Not recently used.

The second room, a cramped and bare thing, was decorated only by four bedrolls on the ground and a pack of Watch supplies in the corner. Dry rations, blackpowder and blades, bandages and liquor. He put it all back into place after having his look.

Tristan went back down, slightly miffed at how the Nineteenth had left nothing at all of use to him. Checking the front door confirmed his suspicion, at least – there was a hair across the doorway that would rip if it were open, kept in place by a nail. He patted himself on the back for having seen that one coming, and the same for the small pots of clay atop the two shutters. Cressida had been clever, he would concede, simply not clever enough.

It was getting late enough he saw no need to linger when there so little to do here, though he spent some time debating whether he should move every piece of furniture around slightly so the Nineteenth would feel a dim sense of discomfort when they returned. Mhm, perhaps next time. He didn’t want to spend the surprise too early, they might start using the place more over the coming weeks.

Besides, the idea of returning more than once without Cressida noticing was rather pleasing.

He was already preparing to leave when he saw lights in the alley, immediately killing his own. Those out in the street were talking quietly, but the voices were young and numerous enough they could only be the returning Nineteenth. Swallowing a smile, Tristan went back to the chimney. He climbed back up, stopped at that spot with a few stones askew and wedged in his feet.

He’d not be able to stay there for long, no more than ten minutes before his legs started shaking too much, but ten minutes was plenty. Sound carried well up the chimney so he would get to eavesdrop his fill so long as they did not head upstairs. It was a good start to overhear Cressida telling the others to stop, checking the hair on the door before opening it.

“No one’s come in since we have,” she told the others.

One for me, Barboza. The brigade piled in, locking the door behind them and lighting some lamps. To his pleasure, they did not waste time before continuing what he learned had been bickering out in the street.

“-omeone could notice he’s missing,” Kiran Agrawal said.

“He’s allowed to visit the city,” Captain Tozi replied, unworried. “There is nothing suspicious about that.”

“This ward has the most brothels in Tratheke, that will be the first assumption,” Cressida said, then her tone hardened. “It is his lateness I dislike.”

“We are late as well,” Izel Coyac pointed out.

“What does it matter for either of us?” Kiran snorted. “We have nothing to report. No progress made.”

Their patron, Captain Oratile, was a woman. It could not be her they were speaking of. So who is it they believe they must report to? It should not be a blackcloak, given that all the officers bunked at Black House and so did the Nineteenth, but who else would they answer to? Their test was the tracking of the contracted killer, Tristan mused, which might mean working with the lictors. Perhaps they had bribed one for information, or a member of some basileia.

Either way, this was turning out much more interesting than he’d expected.

“Letting the heat pass was necessary,” Captain Tozi flatly replied. “There were too many eyes on the business.”

“Kiran speaks true regardless,” Izel said. “We have not pursued the matter any further. That is not a loss but an opportunity – let us tell him that we are finished with…”

Groans from the others.

“Oh, get off that high horse,” Cressida said. “We tried your plan, didn’t we? Paid the guard to grab him. A clean grab with no one hurt, you said.”

And as they kept talking, Tristan’s blood ran cold. Paid the guard? That sounded like…

“And I was wrong,” Izel said. “The man died. I thought this could be done without harm and was proved mistaken. This entire business is sordid and we should be done with it. Besides, given the behavior of the Ivory Library’s men when they were caught at the docks their assurances of good treatment ring hollow.”

“It’s too late for scruples, Izel,” Captain Tozi evenly replied. “Our families made the bargain, it’s on us to deliver. Unless you want your fathers’ tolerance for your career choices to run out?”

“We could-” he began.

Only Coyac was interrupted by a sharp knock on the door. Tristan’s legs ached, but even if they had been bleeding he would have stayed where he was. He would not miss a whisper of this. Someone was ushered in, the man they must have been referring to, and there was the sound of gloves being tossed on a table.

“Let us be done quickly,” a faintly accented voice said, “I do not have long to spend here. How soon can you get us Abrascal?”

Confirmation, part of him icily thought. Someshwari, the rest decided. Not Ramayan, or wherever Kiran Agrawal was from.

“It is delicate work, lieutenant,” Captain Tozi said. “Especially since the fools you also hired got themselves caught and put the Thirteenth’s guard up.”

“I did not come to listen to excuses,” the man replied. “We were promised results in exchange for the favors given.”

Favors to family, it sounded like. Given that Izel Coyac’s father was a prominent Izcalli general this was not a petty matter.

“If he were so easy to grab, you would have done it already,” Cressida mildly replied.

“We do not need to grab him, we already paid your families for it,” the man scorned. “I’ve looked at the Thirteenth and I am less than impressed. The mirror-dancer is a cripple, the captain is stuck in the palace half the time and the savage almost killed herself with her own Signs. How hard can one rat be to catch?”

There was tense silence.

“I have been befriending Song Ren,” Captain Tozi said. “Developing trust. When it is established, we will pick our moment and strike.”

“The ship will only wait so long in the Lordsport,” the man warned. “You will not enjoy the consequences if you fail to deliver.”

Gloves were snatched off the table.

“Do not approach me at Black House,” the man said. “In one week, at the same time, I will return here. There had best be results by then.”

There was shuffling as if someone was getting out of the way, then a door was wrenched open. Though the Nineteenth was sure to continue speaking after this, Tristan did not remain. He hurried up the chimney, as quickly as he could without making noise.

Below were enemies, but there was one in the street as well.

His bag he left on the roof, he would return for it later. He took a lamp, rope, a rag. Careful, careful, he reminded himself as he tread across the tiles. The man was down in the street, already speeding away. Eager to be gone, already gone in his own mind – and that meant he wasn’t paying attention to his surroundings. Tristan slipped back down through the hole in the roof, down the stairs, and was down in the street by the time the stranger turned the corner.

He followed.

In his forties, Someshwari in looks. Short dark hair, narrow shoulders, not the muscles or stride of a fighter. Pistol and knife at his side. His clothes were neither cheap nor expensive, in muted shades that did not stand out. He was headed in the direction of the Collegium, towards the ward’s larger streets – where he would be able to take a coach and Tristan would lose him.

He’d not get there. This was not a nice part of town, and at this hour the streets were mostly empty. Workshops locked up, shutters closed. Taverns full, but there were few around here – and when the stranger turned past one, through an alley, the thief quickened his step. Softly, quick but quiet, watching him peer ahead as Tristan’s fingers closed around his blackjack and he darted through the last of the distance.

It made noise, enough the man turned. But he did not turn quickly enough to avoid the blow on the back of his head. Careful again, so careful – else he might kill the stranger, and the thief did not want that at all. There was no scream, only a groan as the Someshwari dropped. Out cold. Tristan put away the ‘jack and picked up the man. He dragged him away from the tavern, into another side street.

There were three shops there, but only one had a basement with a street entrance. He picked the padlock, checked inside – coal and metal scraps, that would do. He dragged the man down into it, careful not to be seen. Closed the doors, lit a lamp, tied the man up and gagged him before making him look at the wall.

Tristan sliced off his left ear, standing behind him, which woke the Someshwari up. The gag mostly took care of the scream. Blood sprayed, coursing down his neck in small rivers.

“I have questions for you,” the rat said, feigning a deeper voice. “Scream and you will die.”

Dropping the cut ear onto his lap reinforced the point. A tangible, permanent loss at the beginning will strike terror, Abuela had taught him. It will establish from the beginning the stakes of disobeying you. The Someshwari hastily nodded, proving her right again. She was always right.

Tristan lowered the gag.

“Name?”

“Lieutenant Apurva,” he babbled. “I’m a blackcloak, from a Circle. You’re making a mistake, I-”

“Which Circle?” Tristan asked.

The man paused, surprised.

“The Umuthi Society,” he said. “A tinker. I have coin, I could make you rich if you-”

Tristan put the knife against his throat. He took the hint.

“Why are you in Tratheke, Apurva?” he asked.

“I’m part of the delegation to the Lord Rector,” the Someshwari emphasized. “I’m expected, they will look for me. This is all a huge mistake, but if you let me go-”

Tristan sliced at his shoulder through the cloth, shallow, and the man yelped – more in fear than pain.

“Tell me about the Ivory Library,” Tristan ordered.

“The what?” Lieutenant Apurva tried, but when he felt steel against his throat he changed his tune. “Wait, wait! I’m not even a member, I just work with them. All I know is they study contracts and they’re influential, they have men in many free companies.”

His jaw clenched. What had he done to earn their attention? He should be nobody.

“Why,” he said, “are they trying to abduct the boy from the Thirteenth?”

The lieutenant twitched.

“How do you know that?”

Tristan lightly laid the blade against his remaining ear. The man licked his lips.

“His contract, there’s something strange about it,” he said. “I don’t know anything else, I only…”

The thief forced his breathing to remain even. Anger would not serve him. He must be cold as the steel in his hand.

“Who is your contact?” he asked.

There had to be one, someone who would handle the ship and the moving of an abductee. Lieutenant Apurva wriggled, tried to get out of the ropes.

“You have to let me go if I tell you,” he said. “I just-”

The blade dug into the right ear, blood trickling down, and the Someshwari whimpered.

“Sergeant Ledwaba, from the escorts,” he said. “And there’s another, someone high up, but I don’t know who. Ledwaba handles everything with me.”

High up. Brigadier Chilaca, a commander? His fingers clenched around the knife.

“The ship in the Lordsport,” Tristan rasped out. “Give me a name.”

“The Grinning Madcap,” Apurva wept. “That’s everything, I swear. There’s nothing else for me to tell.”

A breath in, a breath out.

Had he been born under a fool’s star, to keep making the same mistake again and again and again? No matter the color of the cloak, he would always be a rat. Meat for the cats.

“No,” Tristan Abrascal agreed. “You have nothing else to tell me.”

He’d not bothered to feign the voice, this time, and Lieutenant Apurva twisted around to look at his face. He got his look, though whatever he might have said was swallowed by a gurgle when Tristan cut his throat.

Blood sprayed on the cellar wall.

He watched his enemy die in silence, mind already racing ahead. The Watch would come looking for him, eventually. They would have contractors, Masks. I must clean up here, he thought, then get rid of the clothes and the body in running water. A canal would suit. Then he must double back for his kit and hurry to Black House, to ensure he was seen and would not stand out as a suspect.

Someone high up, the dead man had said. How high up did it go? No, it did not matter. No matter the rank it was enough he could no longer afford to stay in Black House. He would have to tell Song… Something, an excuse could be made. And Maryam, she- he swallowed. Calm. Fear and the rest, they could wait until he had dug his way out to the grave.

A hand on his shoulder. He did not need to turn to know who it was, for he felt not even a tremor of fear from it. It was as familiar as his own breath.

“What will you do?” Fortuna asked.

He closed his eyes. Tozi Poloko. Kiran Agrawal. Izel Coyac. Cressida Barboza. Hunt him, would they?

“What else?”

His fingers tried to close around a tile that wasn’t there.

“I’m going to kill them all,” the rat said.

47 thoughts on “Chapter 50

  1. So the 19th is in on it huh? This means Cressida is good enough at lying that Tristan couldn’t tell (from several chapters back).

    Ang’s blinders are coming off. She’s starting to separate the difference between honor and nobility. As Tristan noted in Book 1, she’ll be a lot more dangerous for it.

    And Evander made a move!

    A king’s power first sought to preserve itself.

    I try to avoid politics since there’s too many idiots who do that every chapter but this is incredibly accurate. Incredible work from the author.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Damien Hostettler's avatar Damien Hostettler

      Every ruler’s power first sought to preserve itself. That’s the principle: if you don’t stay in power and/or spend power to ensure what the changes you made last, you will not have time to make changes and these changes will not last.

      It even tends to be less an issue with authoritarian ruler who get their power from a “natural law”, like a king of divine mandate.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Scott's Folly's avatar Scott's Folly

        And it is not limited to the individual. Systems of governance are invariably up to perpetuate that system regardless of how the incumbent may change, even or indeed especially if improvements become available.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. arcanavitae15's avatar arcanavitae15

    Angaharad and Maryam are testing the contract and are learning more and more about it. It’s a good thing they communicated to each other about Locke and Key. Also I respect Angharad for owning up internally and externally to how she’s been acting, her debts to settle mantra/realization while hard on her is forcing her to grow.

    Song not letting the Prector walk all over her and the Brigade is great to see, she’s gotten pretty good at this politics thing. I find myself liking Evander he’s pretty cool for a King, Song and the 13th taking him on a wild adventure will go so disastrously horrible I can’t wait to see it. Song is so amused at the concept of taking a king to a brothel.

    Tristain is in his environment when it comes to information gathering.

    Evander and Song had an interesting and tense political debate they both know a lot about the subject and understandably have very different views. Evander and Song do seem to have a thing for each other but it’s not really something either of them. Evander is a decent dude in a horrible position where he’s really miserable and it’s hard not to feel bad for him.

    Tristan went from full on joking around with Fortuna and breaking and entry to full on Rat mode when he learned that the 19th was trying to kidnap him. Tristan has gone back to full on ruthless survivor mode and has been reminded he’s not safe, he’s murked a guy and will be killing the rest of the people who want to hunt him. He also now knows people are after him for his contract which is why they’re hunting him.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. KageLupus's avatar KageLupus

      I don’t trust Evander in the slightest. I think that he is much more experienced in flirting than Song, and sets up situations to make himself or Song look a particular way.

      But that is just manipulation on an emotional/romantic level, and Evander did not keep his crown by making eyes at all the people scheming against him. I think he is using Song as an excuse for more freedom from his usual handlers and him being interested shrine is a good from the “lost” records he promises he hasn’t read…

      Like

      1. Sun Dog's avatar Sun Dog

        weirdly, I was struck by the impulse that at the end of this, Evandro might find someone else to hold down the throne, renounce his title and go on adventures with his pals in the 13th. It seems unlikely, but also a fun idea.

        Like

  3. Frank MC (Abnaxis)'s avatar Frank MC (Abnaxis)

    ohhhh, I just had an epiphany.

    The Theogeny project primarily aimed to find a way to allow a person to have more than one contract. This is normally impossible, because as Remund said earlier, “they go mad and die. The gods eat them from the inside.”

    Presumably Theogeny tried to prevent this, suggesting they were somehow trying to control how well gods can “eat” from their contractor.

    At the end of book 1, Lord Asher of the Obscure committee said Theogeny “used forceful aether taint as a basis for their research.” “Aether taint” is the effect that lucents’ emotions have on the aether that gods and devils feed on. “Forceful aether taint” is tainting aether through the use of torture to increase how much taint the torture victims’ emotions put out.

    When Tristan saw his father die, he was in an exceptionally heightened emotional state. He was just a child who saw his father murdered, in a horrid butcher house surrounded by people both familiar and extremely dangerous. Between the rage and horror and grief and betrayal he was experiencing, to say Tristan was forcefully tainting the aether is probably an understatement. We haven’t gotten a precise time for when Tristan made his contract with Fortuna, but it could have been around this time.

    I think whatever Theogeny was working on has modified the way that Fortuna can “feed” on Tristan, preventing him from becoming a Saint, at a guess by making him become “discordant” as she feeds on his aether taint. That’s why she can manifest all the time. That’s why when he draws too deep Fortuna disappears instead of him becoming Sainted. Theogeny was an accidental success.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Wiwerse's avatar Wiwerse

      Not counting hollows, I’m pretty sure he already has the highest killcount. Counting hollows it becomes a competition though.

      Angie and Song both killed a fair few hollows on the dominion, and Angie also got a few assassins too.

      Maryam and Tristan share credit for the mountain though, which puts them squarely in the lead. Tristan has killed more people onscreen, but Maryam might have a few kills from her time riding with the wintersworn. Still, I’d say Tristan is in the lead quite firmly.

      Like

    2. Scott's Folly's avatar Scott's Folly

      To shoot, no. He knows how much of a liability a loaded gun can be when he starts trading luck, he knows how much attention using it can draw even without that, and he knows how little accuracy he’s been able to achieve with that lack of practice.

      To stab, slice, smash, or squeeze, however…

      Liked by 2 people

  4. Mirror Night's avatar Mirror Night

    Tristan getting his Rambo on but going solo will get him into trouble. not a shocker someone is making a move for him on this island. Much easier to disappear and smuggle him out here outside of Watch direct control. Though I am surprised the White Library doesn’t have their own hunters they can send in. Plausible deniability I guess….

    Nice relationship evolution. Angie is walking into a trap it seems. Fallen family with secret knowledge sounds dangerous.

    Like

    1. Frank MC (Abnaxis)'s avatar Frank MC (Abnaxis)

      Back at the start of the book, Nerei (Abuela) said she was running interference with the White Library, but that she couldn’t do anything about the students trying to nab him. Apparently even the guard that tried to abduct Tristan was doing so because students were paying him for it.

      So the White Library does have its own people, but Tristan does too, and they’re both keeping each other out of Scholomance

      Like

  5. ByVectron!'s avatar ByVectron!

    (whistling) Man! What are the odds that Tristan would happen to be at the right place at the right time, in exactly the right position, to hear th at conversation? Crazycakes, I tell ya.

    Liked by 3 people

  6. trashdragon's avatar trashdragon

    Okay, if all they were to find a wall in a cellar this really could have been just a Tristan mission. I know that hindsight is 20/20 but Song is not helping her situation by being seen going in and out of a literal No-Tell Motel with a guy who’s totally not the Lord Rector.

    And I really do suspect Evander to be up to something at this point. Possibly some plot that involves implicating Song and by extension the Watch in his activities. I don’t know what but Song getting led on this run around just because Evander is down bad seems kinda embarassing for her imo.

    Also for all that Tristan talks about being a rat his reactions when he’s triggered like this come off more like those of a frightened, aggressive predator to me. Rats don’t hunt down and kill things they perceive as a threat to them, lions and tigers do that shit.

    Another potential brick wall for the 13th to run into. If he gets caught trying to team kill he better hope he can expose their plot or else he’s screwed. And I really hope the serial killer Tozi is supposed to be chasing is just a serial killer and they aren’t doing ritualistic serial killer sacrifice to release the Hated One or someting.

    Like

    1. shikkarasu's avatar shikkarasu

      I think it still fits in Rat territory. They can be vicious in their own weight class. Also Tristan knows well enough that hiding isn’t an option; he has already been found. His escape has been cut off. That is exactly when a rat decides to try its luck biting the cat.

      … and he is a very lucky rat.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. trashdragon's avatar trashdragon

        The thing is that I’m not really sure that he is trapped. The 19th were already floundering and now that he’s taken out their contact their plan is in limbo until the higher up contact risks exposure by picking the plot back up.

        Tristan has the initiative here. He knows about their plot, they don’t know he knows, they’re fractious, don’t really have a plan, and their ability to act is constrained by the expectation of completing their assignment on top of hunting Tristan. There seems to be plenty of room for him to maneuver and play the long game, neutralizing their threat in a more gradual and less risky manner, and even turning the whole thing around to his advantage if he can find leverage on the 19th.

        Instead he wants to escalate and proactively go on the offensive with the maximalist murder goals with no regard for consequences beyond his sight. That means far more risk of exposure or direct confrontation, and potentially setting up greater dangers down the line know that he’s made enemies of four more powerful families and possibly the Watch itself.

        And while we’re still on the animal metaphors; no matter how clever or vicious the rat is in the moment it’s still a prey animal, and the cat is a miniature apex predator. The cat only needs a little bit of luck when it pounces, but the rat needs to get lucky always.

        It’s a survival instinct that’s served him well in the murk, but he’s not longer in the murk, and at the end of the day instincts are predictable and stupid. Letting the tail wag the dog by making decisions based on his trauma-born defense mechanisms is THE thing that’s going to get him caught one day IMO.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Will's avatar Will

        (This reply is to @trashdragon, but we’re apparently too nested here.)

        It’s a survival instinct that’s served him well in the murk, but he’s not longer in the murk

        This was literally the mistake Nerei/Abuela highlighted when she ambushed him on the ship to Scholomance: he should have called for help. For this particular hazard, Song and Maryam have already demonstrated a willingness to go to the mat for Tristan, and he should definitely be bringing it to them.

        Liked by 4 people

      3. Some Smartass's avatar Some Smartass

        @trashdragon : Those families will be after him just for being free when they promised him as property to the Ivory Library. May as well be hanged for a sheep as for a lamb, and killing their local assets will make it harder to reach him.

        Liked by 1 person

      4. trashdragon's avatar trashdragon

        @SomeSmartass Except these are family, not just assets. Even if they don’t care about the lives of their children for their own sake, they’ll care about blood. If Tristan kills them there’s a good chance that even if he eliminates the Ivory Library or gets them off his tail the family vendetta may remain to hang over his head.

        And let’s not forget that this isn’t just nobility here. Izel’s family connection is literally Izcalli’s reigning expert on killology. Fucking with a family of grasping aristos is one thing, fucking with the star general of a continent spanning hegemon is entirely another.

        Like

  7. CantankerousBellerophan's avatar CantankerousBellerophan

    The aftermath of poor housing policy is my day job, so in lieu of my usual rant on theory let’s get practical.

    Major differences between Tratheke and a modern city: actual polluting industries exist in Tratheke. There’s little of that left where I am, what with deindustrialization and disinvestment. Transportation doesn’t seem to be a major contributor to pollution in Tratheke. Horses exist and should be a problem, but since nobody is mentioning massive piles of manure on every street corner I’m assuming they’ve invested well in street cleaning and sewers. Some of that manure would be consumed by industry anyway, or exported to farms. Meanwhile, I’m in a heavily car-infested transportation nightmare of a city.

    Similarities: Most everything else? I’m unclear on the population of Tratheke, but it feels about the same size. There’s a wealthy center and largely ignored outskirts. There’s more on-paper individual home ownership, but banks are just a different kind of parasite. Almost everyone is paying some kind of rent. Furthermore, the people who make the city possible have no say on how their city is constructed. Highways slicing right through historically black neighborhoods aren’t that different than a deliberately engineered air quality catastrophe.

    What Song suggests would be more just, but only marginally. More akin to what we’ve done by drowning everyone in car exhaust and aerosolized rubber than a true solution. Giving every neighborhood a poison fountain would just result in the wealthy forcing the poor closer to the local poison fountain, just like we did with highways and what little industry remains. They can’t exile the industries to the outskirts either, that would just result in slums built around them. Given that these industries need to exist (and in this context they do. Tanned leather is useful), what should have been done is attempting to capture fumes and send them into the sewers. But I don’t know if they have the technology for that.

    Song’s solution would make Tratheke more like a modern city, but only in negative ways. The existence of landlords will always mean they can decide who lives where, changing the material conditions won’t improve things unless the social conditions change as well.

    Like

    1. Frank MC (Abnaxis)'s avatar Frank MC (Abnaxis)

      Maybe this is an extreme take but…what if we just put the industry in a place where people don’t live? The only reason it is where it is is for efficiency–in Thratheke, because of the fans, IRL because of transport arteries like rivers or railroads–so its just a matter of will and investment in infrastructure that has any of that crap getting put next to houses.

      That’s the way where I live is currently set up, by accident–the industries that used to clog the center of town around the river went out of business (one actually blew up and took out half of downtown), but newer factories eventually came back, and have been built on the outskirts since the center of town filled up in the interim.

      There’s no NIMBY problem, because nobody was living there anyway. It just takes 20 minutes to drive to work.

      In Tratheke, they could do the same thing. Even at low technology level, the fact that Tratheke roads just exist without maintenance beyond cleaning should make it possible to set up an industrial zone outside of the residential areas and have large capacity horse-drawn carriage carry workers back and forth on a fixed schedule.

      The main issue, I’m intuiting at least, is the cost associated with guarding any disconnected district from wildlife. However, I’m also getting from this chapter that the manpower would be there if they were willing to pay for it.

      Like

      1. CantankerousBellerophan's avatar CantankerousBellerophan

        There are two technological limits in play here and one of them is physically insurmountable.

        First, Vesper doesn’t seem to have the technical or organizational capacity to construct effective and safe mass transit systems. They have irreplaceable Antediluvian relics, horses, feet, and nothing in between. They are just now inventing mass reproduceable rifles, so they don’t have the metallurgic knowledge to invent bikes better than penny-farthings. I’d imagine there’s someone tinkering in Tianxia or the Clockwork Cathedral on such things, but the materials just aren’t there. Furthermore, we know they have crude steam engines, but the existence of Antediluvian aether engines is suppressing that field of study. Why bother making a clumsy physical machine when you are surrounded by strictly superior magical ones? They could try horse-drawn trolleys, but those require ripping up Antediluvian roads to install, and would massively increase horse traffic. This would worsen air quality everywhere. Anything increasing dependence on horses is a non-starter from a public health perspective.

        Second, and I recommend actually doing this, go outside your front door, look around, and estimate how much of the land you see is dedicated solely to cars. Roads, parking lots, driveways, garages. This technology is a titanic waste of physical space. Instead of putting destinations closer together so you don’t need so much transportation infrastructure, cars have demanded we spread them out massively just to accomodate this waste. Furthermore, full implementation of cars absolutely wrecks cities. Large sections of city center (usually populated by poor and PoC communities, because of course) demolished and replaced with impassable, loud, sightline-wrecking lines of air and ground pollution. The need for parking to get business strangles the businesses which used to exist there and weren’t built around that requirement, and the people who used to live and work in and near them are forced out so they can park their newly required cars. This system would be a global ecological disaster even ignoring climate change. And I haven’t even mentioned “accidents,” a name literally given to car collisions by car companies to absolve themselves of responsibility in the public eye.

        This waste of a system is the insurmountable technical problem. Cars are bad. Irredeemably so. There is no fixing the flaws with such a system, as they are hard requirements for the system to accomplish anything at all. So your suggestion of a “20 minute drive” actually maximizes injustice, because the system required to make that possible is maximally unjust. I don’t blame you for thinking this way. Most people haven’t considered how bad our transportation situation really is. Ultimately, if we want humanity to have a future, cars must be banned globally, and trucks and other personal transports heavily limited or jobs redesigned entirely so we don’t need them. There is no way around that.

        Your suggestion, while a good one on paper, requires technology Vesper does not have, or a self-engineered disaster on par with the collapse of the First Empire.

        Like

      2. Some Smartass's avatar Some Smartass

        @CantankerousBellerophan: Aren’t you ignoring rural areas that are, by definition, spread out anyway? I suppose that’s not relevant to the specific scenario, though.

        Like

      3. Frank MC (Abnaxis)'s avatar Frank MC (Abnaxis)

        Ignoring the rest of Vesper since we were talking about Tratheke specifically, their technical hurdles are bypassed by them living in an Antediluvian ruin. Horsebuses exited, and were only replaced horse trams that ran on rails because rails are a much higher quality surface to drive on than crappy 19th-century roads, most of which were unpaved. Tratheke benefits from ancient-built, maintenance-free, smooth roads–they can just hitch some horses to a 50-person-capacity omnibus and send it where it needs to go, within city limits. No rails needed.

        Speaking more broadly, to the “scourge” of traffic infrastructure, I have listened to the arguments for that position. I find most of them to be myopic pandering that feels like the same arguments that enable “reduce, reuse, recycle” or “if everyone just unplugged their unused chargers it would save millions of watts of power.” They’re corporate smokescreens meant to shift blame onto individual consumers for all the ills of society, rather than institutional actors who can actually solve them.

        Take pollution for example. The reason why we have so much vehicle pollution today isn’t because we have roads, it’s because we have intellectual property laws which permit an entity to buy up technological patents with absolutely no intention of producing the technology named in the patent–thus suppressing that technology from coming to market. We would have had alternative fuels for vehicles at least thirty years ago if it weren’t for oil conglomerates snapping up every alternative fuel distribution technology they could get their hands on and sitting on them. I know this, because I worked on just such an alternative fuel twenty years ago–high energy-density cells that can be recharged in low-temperature solar-concentration furnaces–that went nowhere because any patent released for actually distributing those fuel cells was suppressed. The only reason we’re starting to see EVs introduced now is because the corporations missed out on suppressing lithium-ion rechargeable cells.

        While we’re at it let’s talk about the fact that while cars get a massive, massive lot of media airtime for greenhouse gas emissions, it’s not the largest source of your smog-clogged skylines. That would be our omnipresent coal-burning power plants. And yet, nuclear power–which, broadly speaking, is the least environmentally-impactful large-scale power generation method we’ve come up with that’s actually practical–has been around since the 60s. It’s never been widely adopted, but I bet the rampant fear-mongering and lack of education for the technology was just coincidence and not because the coal industry wields a massive amount of political leverage on the people making the decisions. It’s easier to blame climate change on silly rural Americans who buy pickup trucks and SUVs, so let’s just do that instead.

        And that’s before we even get into the economics of high density housing, and how and why it becomes so exceptionally expensive. I have lived in both large metropolitan areas and remote rural, and let me tell you that even though I lived in a high-crime area the difference in quality of life was STARK when I lived in the city. When my son had a rare skin condition it was no big deal–the specialist doctor he needed was close enough I didn’t even need to take off a full day of work for appointments. For this and other professional services or governmental services or employment opportunities or educational services, I had much less trouble finding what I needed for day to day life and for career advancement.

        And the thing is, this makes sense from an actual, practical standpoint. You only need so many pediatric rheumatologists per capita. There only need to be so many vocational education facilities or research institutions or provincial government offices. There might not be ENOUGH of them–especially the pediatric rheumatologists–but we don’t need so many of them it makes sense to put them in every podunk backwater.

        The demand for those services and opportunities is what brings about exceptionally high urban costs of living, at an order of magnitude much higher than packing people more densely without automobile infrascturcture would ever be able to make up. Remember, you’re not going to be able to be ride of ALL transport infrastructure–even if you got rid of all the extraneous parking spots, you’re only going to get maybe 20-30% more build-able area for residences and commercial buildings? Meanwhile, the house I’m living in now would have sold for literally twenty times what I paid for it if it was located in the city I moved from. The magnitudes aren’t even remotely close.

        All you accomplish by removing automobile infrastructure is give a collective middle finger to the disenfranchised and to untrained laborers–the people who serve the food, mop the floors, and clean the windows for the hospitals and campuses you’ve prettied up and made walk-able for the rich who live near them–who have to jump through more hurdles to access those buildings.

        I know this, because I’ve SEEN it–this is how your average residential college campus is set up. They’re designed with an underlying assumption that students will be housed in local high-density dormitories, with minimal parking or pick-up/drop-off areas. They then charge exorbitant amounts for those dorms, $2K+/month (in 2006 dollars) for a bed in a shared postage-stamped-size apartment, and if you have the audacity to be a first-generation college student who can’t afford all that while also paying for food and medicine so you move off-campus, the only available parking will be on the periphery of the campus, at a minimum a 25 minute walk one-way from any actual classroom. Hope you didn’t need a job while you study!

        What you propose is the same, but at larger scale. An organization of society with a rarefied few who can afford to live in luxury unmitigated by that bothersome infrastructure daring to disturb their sight-lines. A city where those same neighborhoods that get demolished for overpasses instead gentrified–those same disadvantaged and PoC will still be driven out, and saddled with less mobility when you’re finished. What you speak is the refrain of over-entitled elitists advocating for segregation to ban the unwashed masses from “wrecking” their walled gardens, masquerading as ethical liberal policy.

        I’ve LIVED that, and it’s very much more unjust than the alternative. The roads aren’t the problem.

        Liked by 1 person

      4. CantankerousBellerophan's avatar CantankerousBellerophan

        I am not talking about fuel. Fuel is undoubetedly the most pressing immediate issue with the system, but it’s also physically surmountable. There are technologies which could replace ICE, as you note. The problems are deeper than that.

        For one, fuel emissions aren’t the only form of air pollution coming from cars. They might not even be the most dangerous, given that most of the plastics found in the bloodstreams of every living thing come from aerosolized tires. Makes sense in retrospect. Tires are by far the most common petrochemical-based consumable product, and their use shreds them into the air and runoff. In addition, there is a salt cycle much like the water cycle. The salt cycle is currently being disrupted by dumping millions of tons of salt on roads every winter. Third, there is zero coherent plan to handle end-of-life disposal for cars. I deal with that fact in my day job. We sell people these massive chunks of steel and plastic, and they just stay out there in the environment forever unless someone actively hauls them off.

        It sounds like your solution to the fuel problem isn’t lithium-based, but as you so rightly note, fuel cell technology has been sidelined in favor of batteries. To replace the current car fleet of just the United States with EVs would require an order of magnitude more lithium than is currently mined each year. Ramping up production would basically mean strip-mining Bolivia against its will, and the same goes for every other exotic material going into any hypothetical ICE replacement. And the electrical power used just in computing power to run current EV models replacing the US ICE fleet would rival that of Argentina. I don’t know if that is a problem for your solution, but I can tell you this: A fuel cell is a battery, and all batteries are bombs. When LI batteries are breached, such as in collisions, they become inextinguishable, toxic fireballs. No matter what method you are using to store energy for later release, the unexpected destabilization of the storage medium will always result in catastrophic failure as the energy escapes. And if the storage medium is too stable to explode, it can’t be used as a battery because that instability is what the energy comes from.

        But not even that problem is insurmountable. Insurmountable problems with car infrastructure include, but are not limited to:

        • The costs of purchasing, maintaining, and removing EoL vehicles is placed entirely on the consumer. I’d think most poor people would be better off if instead of spending a fortune on that, they could spend significantly less on fares for a mass transit system which met the same needs. Such a system can exist and does in many cities around the world. Or, better, if such a system were funded through progressive tax structures.
        • The positive feedback loop of car infrastructure I previously alluded to. Because this system consumes prodigious space to move not that many people per unit land area, anywhere you want to go with the system must necessarily be further away than it could be otherwise. If you spend half the land in a county on cars, it follows that the city is twice as large as it otherwise might be if, for instance, it were possible to put all long and medium-distance travel underground where it spends effectively zero surface space. Cutting down the size of the city means you need less transit infrastructure overall because the city being covered is smaller, and this sword cuts both ways. Your son’s doctor could have been even closer. Urban sprawl happened entirely because most of the land area in cities and outlying areas was consumed in roads and parking minimums, and now that cities are so large we require even more cars to traverse them, which increases the size of the city while worsening traffic and ballooning outlays on maintenance of this ravenous beast which eats land, lives, and the biosphere as a whole. Every square foot of land which isn’t spent on transportation infrastructure can be spent on things which human beings, rather than their machines, can use.
        • Manufacturing does spend most of our global carbon budget, but you know what is manufactured? Cars. Steel mills emit enormous amounts of greenhouse gas whose product is spent building cars and roads. The chemical reaction which produces the slaked lime in concrete releases carbon dioxide, and most of our concrete goes into roads. To say nothing of asphalt, which is even worse. Two steel rails transporting a million people a day are significantly more efficient than the thousands of roads necessary to do the same.

        These problems cannot be avoided by car based systems. They are baked in, and remain problems even if we decarbonize the engines. And I haven’t even mentioned collision deaths, but 100% of those can also be avoided by simply eliminating individual, crash-prone vehicles. Cars are the second least safe mode of transportation behind only helicopters. Defending them is frankly absurd.

        Like

      5. Frank MC (Abnaxis)'s avatar Frank MC (Abnaxis)

        I bristle to call anything we’re discussing here a “solution.” If anything, they are missed opportunities to avoid what we both see as pernicious societal problems. For the much of it, it’s too late to reclaim area taken up by much of the “wasted” automobile, you’d have to demolish neighboring buildings as well to make use of it. By the same token, my research has been mothballed since roughly 2008, and would need at lest a couple decades to be implemented.

        However, since this seems to be an area of interest to you, my specific research was into a fuel–zinc–which is both extremely stable and non-toxic. In theory, it would be used to create zinc-air fuel cells in much the same way as hydrogen was once proposed as an alternative fuel–electrolysis would convert zinc oxide (instead of water) into zinc (hydrogen) at high temperature, which would then be used in an air-cathode fuel cell, which would generate zinc-oxide (water) that could be recycled into more fuel. Unlike hydrogen, zinc is a solid, stable metal at room temperature. Almost every steel things you’ve encountered that isn’t stainless steel is coated with zinc and zinc-oxide (i.e. galvanized). The only real barrier would have been establishing a distribution network for the cells themselves.

        Additionally, I have little doubt that aerosolized rubbers and disrupting the salt balance, BOTH of those phenomenon are only recently discovered. Salt has alternatives that aren’t harmful, but aren’t established becuase the paper on the salt cycle literally came out last year.

        I’m less familiar with the issues with rubber, but I’ve done enough engineering to know both that the current rubber in use has been value engineered to be exactly as sturdy as it was though was necessary and no more, and that there are literally thousands of polymeric compounds currently in use with different physical and health effects, and we haven’t even scratched the surface. There have been great advancement in NMR spectroscopy in the last decade, which have greatly expanded the ability for chemists to develop new polymers beyond what we could previously achieve. Now that we know what to look for, I doubt the rubber problem is going to be one for long.

        Regarding your bulleted points:

        • What EoL costs are you referring to specifically? As I understand, most of any car disposed of is recycled, and most scrapyards pay you for it? Or are you referring to the costs associated unexpected breakdowns due to being stuck with very old EoL cars? The problem with mass transit, which I tried to allude to above, is that it costs TIME. If you have to work 60+ hours a week to make ends meet, every minute wasted matters. Even if you just convert time to minimum wage–which grossly undervalues it–an extra 15 minutes added to a commute one-way ultimately costs $100/month, just to go back and forth to work; never mind going to the doctor or buying food. And in my experience, 15 minutes is being generous between the walk and the lack of synchronization of work schedules with transit schedules. Taking my college campus example above, my college had a regular schedule of shuttles that went back and forth from the remote parking lots, but I still walked because the 20 minute walk was shorter than arriving 30 minutes early to catch the shuttle that wouldn’t make me late for class.
        • Respectfully, double the area of the city takes up does not double the space between locations–that’s not how geometry works. Land area goes up quadratically with cross-sectional distance, while trip length increases linearly. Take a circle for example: The furthest distance I can travel within a circle is the diameter, but the area of the circle is pi/4 times diameter squared. That means if I double the area of the circle, I only increase travel distance by 100 times square-root-2 minus 1, or roughly 41%. This is true for any 2-dimensional, convex shape, the only difference is that other shapes have a different constant than pi/4. And again, this is all aside from the fact that the distance isn’t what matters, travel time is. All those “unnecessary” roads increase throughput, so it’s much less than 41% increased travel time.
        • Manufacturing doesn’t spend most of our carbon footprint, energy does. Manufacturing is the largest share of that energy, barely more than transportation at roughly 30%, but it’s not enough to draw an equivalence to between the carbon cost of power generation and the cost of manufacturing. More importantly, this all misses the point that we should be replacing the coal-fired power plants instead of pointing fingers at the practices we don’t like and trying to take their energy away–the idea that if we just wasted less power all our climate problems would go away is a corporate smokescreen for the ACTUAL solutions to the problems that keeps everyone standing off instead of doing anything productive. As an aside, if the carbon released by slaked lime production registers even as a blip compared to that released by coal-fired power plants, I will genuinely be surprised. Every bubble from a carbonated beverage also releases CO2 into the atmosphere, but it’s not enough to be a priority at the moment.

        Like

      6. I’m not sure how the discussion went from “maybe people shouldn’t live in the industrial district” to a discussion about car dependency.

        You can absolutely have separate zoning districts with minimal public infrastructure.

        (And that’s kind of irrelevant anyway because Song’s argument is that people poison themselves *working* there, not living there.)

        Like

      7. Frank MC (Abnaxis)'s avatar Frank MC (Abnaxis)

        @poignardazur Song only explicitly mentions people working there, but in his rebuttal Evander says that when the industries weren’t concentrated, the people living near them revolted. He also said the cost of moving families involved in relocating the industries would be prohibitive. Both these points suggest that there is both housing and industry intermingled, and that it’s poisoning the people living there.

        Additionally, the next point not explicitly stated, but my presumption is that people live near those industries because A: they’re poor, and nobody else wants to live there, or B: they work in those industries and the only available transportation over a distance to get them far enough away to not be living downwind is (expensive) hired coaches.

        My solution to this conundrum, is to separate the residences from the industries, and spread the industries out (right now they’re clustered around canal arteries). Since that makes the industries more remote, I think that would also necessitate the creation of a transportation system that’s cheap enough the workers can use it to commute

        Cantankerous responded that (paraphrasing) the same transport system I’m advocating for is worse than the industries, based on long-term health consequences from over-building infrastructure. I vehemently disagree, so we wound up in a discussion about car dependancy.

        Like

      8. CantankerousBellerophan's avatar CantankerousBellerophan

        In my city, and I assume others with similar car dependence, dead vehicles are only sometimes recycled. In my work area alone (not the poorest area of the city, but certainly not well off) there are likely thousands of vehicles which will never be driven again rotting on residential property as people, for various reasons, refuse to sell or junk them. My job is partially to force people to remove these vehicles, but I am one person. I can’t get them all. So the end of life for these vehicles is to leech fluids into the groundwater, provide habitats for mice, rats, and mosquitoes, and for their petrochemical components to slowly disintegrate, all on residential property. This is a bad enough health risk that my dangerously stingy state hires people (my department) to mitigate the damage. The plan, for EOL vehicles, is literally to let the health department deal with it.

        You’re correct that I did the math wrong on trip times, but not entirely wrong. Due to induced demand and the aforementioned sprawl effect, average trip times do not increase linearly with distance in heavily trafficked systems. The more people are required to use cars, the less efficient the system to facilitate them must be, both because increasing capacity always increases demand more than the added capacity can handle, and because increasing capacity almost always requires driving out places for that capacity to serve even further to the outskirts. Removing car capacity and replacing it with literally any more space efficient capacity alleviates this, as well as causing induced demand to swing the other way.

        And mass transit only costs time if the system is inefficient, and only in the immediate perspective. Time isn’t money, but money is definitely time, and the amount of time people spend to maintain their vehicles is enormous. Several hundred dollars a month in fuel, repairs, and payments will take dozens of hours for low-income people to afford. Meanwhile, yearly unlimited passes for many large mass transit systems in the US cost a fraction that amount, and many localities even provide subsidies to low-income households. There’s just no comparison on cost.

        I looked into zinc fuel cells, and my primary concern is still that batteries are bombs. Zinc powder is flammable. Maybe that can be prevented by suspending the powder in some fire retardant electrolyte gel, but all that can do is increase the flashpoint of the battery. Not remove it entirely. It will still be possible for some electrical fault or just plain poor treatment by the owner to set it alight, and then you have a mobile metal powder fire. I would prefer to head this risk off at the pass by powering nearly all transportation through overhead wires to the nearest nuclear plant.

        Like

      9. Frank MC (Abnaxis)'s avatar Frank MC (Abnaxis)

        Again, I feel like it’s disingenuous to talk about zinc fuel cells as though they’ve ever been a serious contender for alternative fuel. The only solar electrolysis technology that has ever gotten significant funding is solar hydrogen. At the same time, I will note that pretty much all electrical infrastructure carries with it some sort of fire risk that needs mitigated. The worst wildfires recorded were started by power lines, which would need to be expanded if it were to be used for all transportation. This is a significant reason why I would have preferred the solution to alternative fuels to involve more physical transportation of power mediums rather than plug-in vehicles, but that’s not how history unfolded.

        More practically, I’ve personally worked on the electronics used (in part) in fuel storage tanks, with zero catastrophic failures because they’ve been engineered to make sure such failures are vanishingly improbable. Working out a way to distribute things like fuel cells, gas, and/or electricity in an intrinsically safe and economically sound way is a big reason why mechanical engineering exists as a discipline, and that engineering hasn’t been done for zinc fuel cells. That’s why they need 20+ more years of development.

        However, the reason why I’m posting now at all, is because I am genuinely flabbergasted that your professional responsibility to force people to junk vehicles exists at all.

        You get, what, $500 on average scrapping a car, even counting towing cost? It’s baffling that people need convinced to do that. Where I live, people will scrap and/or pilfer anything they can get their hands on. We had a real problem with copper theft–from occupied homes in some cases!–until our law enforcement forced scrapyards to keep photographs of anyone who scraps copper. My in-laws used to have people digging through their trash on a regular basis looking for cans, until those same in-laws started separating the cans themselves for other relatives to scrap. Hell, every local restaurant charges for sauce packets, because if they don’t people will walk off with bags of them instead of buying ketchup/mustard/whatever by the bottle from a grocery store.

        The only thing I can figure, is that you must operate in an area where the cost of living is so high that $500 is somehow just a drop in the bucket compared to living expenses. Where I live, my aunt rents half a duplex with a basement, living room, dining room, and 3 bedrooms for $800/month. I’m pretty sure $500 is two month’s rent in HUD housing–it used to be closer to three months, but I haven’t interacted with HUD in the last 20 years so my info might be dated.

        Leaving $500 on the table is NUTS, from my perspective.

        Like

      10. CantankerousBellerophan's avatar CantankerousBellerophan

        My city is one of the lowest COL large cities in the country, and my work area is on the lower end of the local average. Handling cases to remove junk vehicles from residential property isn’t all I do, but it is maybe 20% of the job. I do it at least once a day unless higher priorities intervene. My impression is that it’s usually people who think they can fix their old junkheaps, or else people who are convinced said junkheaps are collectable or worth a lot to the right buyer. Check your local ordinances for something about removing abandoned vehicles from private property. There definitely is one, because if there weren’t your entire area would be a junkyard.

        Your confusion as to why this would be a problem is sensible…but the problem isn’t based on sense. It’s a default option problem. The fact is there is no automatic system for retrieving vehicles once they become scrap, so the default is dissolving into the ground wherever they park for the last time. Doing anything else requires effort, which is why nothing else happens until the health department steps in. There isn’t really a way to engineer a different default option on a system where everyone personally owns an individual massive machine, either. Trade in programs at auto dealers help, but not everyone takes advantage of them and you need an up-to-date title to use them, which is often not available. When you sell people millions of individually owned machines, one of the consequences is junked machines everywhere.

        This is a foundational flaw in car-based systems which I didn’t even realize existed until I got my job. My final project for my degree was a 40 page diatribe on the catastrophic health impacts of car infrastructure on just my city, and I entirely missed the trash angle which is now 20% of what I do.

        I think it’s a perspective problem. We’ve all been trained by decades of car and oil industry propaganda to see the harms caused by both industries as negligible or worth the benefits, or else outright not see them at all. We’ve never seen a world which didn’t have these problems, so we can’t imagine that world. Capitalist realism, the unshakeable conviction that the current global economic paradigm is the only way things could possibly be and all others would be worse, is an object of study in leftwing circles, but part of that is something I and others have taken to calling car realism. The unquestionable and unexamined faith that the transportation paradigm of the United States is the best way to move things around. That because we’re the “greatest nation on Earth” necessarily means our transportation must be as well. That cars “make us free.” That the people who built this system knew what they were doing, had considered the consequences, had the best interests of everyone at heart when they did it, and that the fruits of that labor should be taken as immutable backgrounds to our lives rather than the products of conscious human intervention. People believe all of that. Worse, they don’t realize they believe it. Angharad still believes the lie of noble privilege in the same way, as a foundation of everything she does rather than a conscious choice. It’s maddening for those of us who have stepped out.

        Like

  8. Nix Jasra's avatar Nix Jasra

    Is nobody going to mention the wine? Evander seems supernaturally shady right now.

    But then again, I’m the one who carries the 10ft pole, so I could just be jumping at shadows. Still. *watching you* Evander.

    Like

  9. Someperson's avatar Someperson

    Angharad is absolutely about to find herself inundated up to her eyeballs in spooky cult shit with house Eirenos.

    Ironically, I’m pretty sure Tristan may have just done Angharad a solid by murdering Apurva, as it seems likely from context that Apurva was the member of the Watch delegation going to see the docks that Angharard was worried about recognizing the infernal forge.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. Someperson's avatar Someperson

    You know, with the revelation that the folks hunting Tristan are motivated by his strange contract, the fact that they’re going to such lengths to capture him alive is suddenly a lot more sinister.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Sun Dog's avatar Sun Dog

      they apparently study contracts. They may have a sniffer like Song able to give some details, but a corpse is just inherently less useful for giving answers. Particularly if the contract doesn’t alter his body or is voided by his death. Presumably, the Library has done this thing before, a lot.

      Like

      1. nick012000's avatar nick012000

        I think its also possible that his Abuela leaked the information to them deliberately as a test and learning experience for him.

        Like

  11. I kind of find myself on Evander’s side in his debate with Song over governance.

    If the Republics keep fighting each other and maintaining an extremely corrupt ruling class with a thin veneer of meritocracy, then “But even few years we elect rulers who swear they will totally fix the system this time” isn’t really a good argument for their system over hereditary monarchy.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yeah, he’s got something of a point. Song says it’s about the method, but the thing is, their method is just a different kind of shitty.

      As long as you only have a republic, but no true democracy, you merely replaced a heritable aristocracy with an elected one, but it’s very much still ruling class, and so will still always serve itself first.

      With Song merely reciting the founding myth that’s supposed to justify her totally-not-noble family’s own rule over their alleged peers, before their downfall anyway.

      Well, at least they won’t have to deal with completely mad kings like the one in Izcalli for any prolonged period of time anymore, which is at least marginally better, but still only so much.

      Like

  12. The Thirteenth looks to be as unlucky as their name implies, poor Tristan.

    This does delightfully reframe alot of the 19ths earlier interactions very well. With Tozi sneaking Bait into the party to get information on the 13th and Tristan, and Cressida tailing Tristan to the Chimerical to make sure they shared classes. I am curious if whoever decided on the Asphodel brigades was in on it, or if there was enough overlap between brigades to send them together.

    What interests me is the payment for the 19th, which was seemingly some sort of favour or bargain for the families of the 19th, and “its on them to deliver”. I’m curious what kind of bargain it could be, maybe to let them go to the Scholomance at all? I’m not seeing how the 19th feels any need to keep up their side, as it would probably be super difficult for them to get tossed out of the Watch.

    I’m excited to see what comes next. I do have a soft spot for Izel so I hope he jumps ship. Damn EE for making me attached to antagonists.

    Like

Leave a reply to onedollargum Cancel reply